| Big East All Conference Team Selections - by School |
15 different Syracuse University players have made the All Big East First Team a total of 25 times.
| Player | Team | Season | School |
| Antonio Granger | Third Team | 1997-1998 | Boston College |
| Bill Curley | Second Team | 1991-1992 | Boston College |
| Bill Curley | First Team | 1992-1993 | Boston College |
| Bill Curley | First Team | 1993-1994 | Boston College |
| Craig Smith | Second Team | 2002-2003 | Boston College |
| Craig Smith | First Team | 2003-2004 | Boston College |
| Craig Smith | First Team | 2004-2005 | Boston College |
| Dana Barros | Second Team | 1986-1987 | Boston College |
| Dana Barros | First Team | 1987-1988 | Boston College |
| Dana Barros | Second Team | 1988-1989 | Boston College |
| Danya Abrams | First Team | 1994-1995 | Boston College |
| Danya Abrams | First Team | 1995-1996 | Boston College |
| Danya Abrams | First Team | 1996-1997 | Boston College |
| Duane Woodward | Third Team | 1997-1998 | Boston College |
| Dwan Chandler | Third Team | 1980-1981 | Boston College |
| Howard Eisley | Second Team | 1992-1993 | Boston College |
| Howard Eisley | Second Team | 1993-1994 | Boston College |
| Jared Dudley | First Team | 2004-2005 | Boston College |
| Jay Murphy | Second Team | 1982-1983 | Boston College |
| Jay Murphy | First Team | 1983-1984 | Boston College |
| Joe Beaulieu | Third Team | 1979-1980 | Boston College |
| John Bagley | First Team | 1980-1981 | Boston College |
| John Bagley | First Team | 1981-1982 | Boston College |
| John Garris | Second Team | 1982-1983 | Boston College |
| Michael Adams | Second Team | 1982-1983 | Boston College |
| Michael Adams | Second Team | 1983-1984 | Boston College |
| Michael Adams | Second Team | 1984-1985 | Boston College |
| Roger McCready | Third Team | 1985-1986 | Boston College |
| Troy Bell | First Team | 2000-2001 | Boston College |
| Troy Bell | First Team | 2001-2002 | Boston College |
| Troy Bell | First Team | 2002-2003 | Boston College |
| Deonta Vaughn | First Team | 2007-2008 | Cincinnati |
| Eric Hicks | First Team | 2005-2006 | Cincinnati |
| A.J. Price | First Team | 2007-2008 | Connecticut |
| Ben Gordon | Second Team | 2002-2003 | Connecticut |
| Ben Gordon | First Team | 2003-2004 | Connecticut |
| Caron Butler | Third Team | 2000-2001 | Connecticut |
| Caron Butler | First Team | 2001-2002 | Connecticut |
| Charlie Villanueva | Second Team | 2004-2005 | Connecticut |
| Chris Smith | Second Team | 1989-1990 | Connecticut |
| Chris Smith | Second Team | 1990-1991 | Connecticut |
| Chris Smith | First Team | 1991-1992 | Connecticut |
| Chuck Aleksinas | Second Team | 1980-1981 | Connecticut |
| Cliff Robinson | Third Team | 1987-1988 | Connecticut |
| Cliff Robinson | Second Team | 1988-1989 | Connecticut |
| Corny Thompson | Second Team | 1979-1980 | Connecticut |
| Corny Thompson | First Team | 1980-1981 | Connecticut |
| Corny Thompson | First Team | 1981-1982 | Connecticut |
| Donny Marshall | Third Team | 1993-1994 | Connecticut |
| Donny Marshall | Third Team | 1994-1995 | Connecticut |
| Donyell Marshall | First Team | 1992-1993 | Connecticut |
| Donyell Marshall | First Team | 1993-1994 | Connecticut |
| Doron Sheffer | Third Team | 1993-1994 | Connecticut |
| Doron Sheffer | Second Team | 1994-1995 | Connecticut |
| Doron Sheffer | Second Team | 1995-1996 | Connecticut |
| Earl Kelley | Second Team | 1984-1985 | Connecticut |
| Earl Kelley | Second Team | 1985-1986 | Connecticut |
| Emeka Okafor | Third Team | 2001-2002 | Connecticut |
| Emeka Okafor | First Team | 2002-2003 | Connecticut |
| Emeka Okafor | First Team | 2003-2004 | Connecticut |
| Hasheem Thabeet | Second Team | 2007-2008 | Connecticut |
| Hilton Armstrong | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Connecticut |
| James White | Honorable Mention | 2005-2006 | Connecticut |
| Jeff Adrien | Second Team | 2006-2007 | Connecticut |
| Jeff Adrien | First Team | 2007-2008 | Connecticut |
| Josh Boone | Second Team | 2004-2005 | Connecticut |
| Josh Boone | Honorable Mention | 2005-2006 | Connecticut |
| Karl Hobbs | Third Team | 1983-1984 | Connecticut |
| Kevin Ollie | Third Team | 1994-1995 | Connecticut |
| Khalid El-Amin | Third Team | 1997-1998 | Connecticut |
| Khalid El-Amin | Second Team | 1998-1999 | Connecticut |
| Khalid El-Amin | First Team | 1999-2000 | Connecticut |
| Marcus Williams | Third Team | 2004-2005 | Connecticut |
| Marcus Williams | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Connecticut |
| Mike McKay | Third Team | 1979-1980 | Connecticut |
| Mike McKay | Third Team | 1980-1981 | Connecticut |
| Mike McKay | Second Team | 1981-1982 | Connecticut |
| Nadav Henefeld | Third Team | 1989-1990 | Connecticut |
| Rashad Anderson | Honorable Mention | 2005-2006 | Connecticut |
| Ray Allen | First Team | 1994-1995 | Connecticut |
| Ray Allen | First Team | 1995-1996 | Connecticut |
| Richard Hamilton | First Team | 1997-1998 | Connecticut |
| Richard Hamilton | First Team | 1998-1999 | Connecticut |
| Rod Sellers | Third Team | 1991-1992 | Connecticut |
| Rudy Gay | First Team | 2005-2006 | Connecticut |
| Scott Burrell | Third Team | 1990-1991 | Connecticut |
| Scott Burrell | Second Team | 1991-1992 | Connecticut |
| Scott Burrell | Third Team | 1992-1993 | Connecticut |
| Taliek Brown | Honorable Mention | 2003-2004 | Connecticut |
| Tate George | Third Team | 1989-1990 | Connecticut |
| Draelon Burns | Honorable Mention | 2006-2007 | DePaul |
| Draelon Burns | Second Team | 2007-2008 | DePaul |
| Sammy Mejia | Second Team | 2006-2007 | DePaul |
| Wilson Chandler | Second Team | 2006-2007 | DePaul |
| Allen Iverson | Second Team | 1994-1995 | Georgetown |
| Allen Iverson | First Team | 1995-1996 | Georgetown |
| Alonzo Mourning | Second Team | 1988-1989 | Georgetown |
| Alonzo Mourning | First Team | 1989-1990 | Georgetown |
| Alonzo Mourning | Third Team | 1990-1991 | Georgetown |
| Alonzo Mourning | First Team | 1991-1992 | Georgetown |
| Bill Martin | Second Team | 1984-1985 | Georgetown |
| Brandon Bowman | Third Team | 2004-2005 | Georgetown |
| Charles Smith | Second Team | 1987-1988 | Georgetown |
| Charles Smith | First Team | 1988-1989 | Georgetown |
| Craig Shelton | First Team | 1979-1980 | Georgetown |
| David Wingate | Second Team | 1983-1984 | Georgetown |
| David Wingate | Third Team | 1984-1985 | Georgetown |
| David Wingate | Second Team | 1985-1986 | Georgetown |
| Dikembe Mutombo | Second Team | 1989-1990 | Georgetown |
| Dikembe Mutombo | First Team | 1990-1991 | Georgetown |
| Dwayne Bryant | Third Team | 1989-1990 | Georgetown |
| Eric Floyd | Second Team | 1979-1980 | Georgetown |
| Eric Floyd | First Team | 1980-1981 | Georgetown |
| Eric Floyd | First Team | 1981-1982 | Georgetown |
| Eric Smith | Second Team | 1980-1981 | Georgetown |
| Eric Smith | Third Team | 1981-1982 | Georgetown |
| Gerald Riley | Third Team | 2003-2004 | Georgetown |
| Jeff Green | Honorable Mention | 2004-2005 | Georgetown |
| Jeff Green | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Georgetown |
| Jeff Green | First Team | 2006-2007 | Georgetown |
| Jerome Williams | Third Team | 1994-1995 | Georgetown |
| Jerome Williams | Third Team | 1995-1996 | Georgetown |
| Joey Brown | Third Team | 1991-1992 | Georgetown |
| John Duren | First Team | 1979-1980 | Georgetown |
| Jonathan Wallace | Honorable Mention | 2006-2007 | Georgetown |
| Jonathan Wallace | Honorable Mention | 2007-2008 | Georgetown |
| Kevin Braswell | Second Team | 2000-2001 | Georgetown |
| Kevin Braswell | Third Team | 2001-2002 | Georgetown |
| Mark Tilimon | First Team | 1989-1990 | Georgetown |
| Michael Jackson | Third Team | 1983-1984 | Georgetown |
| Michael Jackson | Third Team | 1984-1985 | Georgetown |
| Michael Jackson | Third Team | 1985-1986 | Georgetown |
| Michael Sweetney | First Team | 2001-2002 | Georgetown |
| Mike Sweetney | First Team | 2002-2003 | Georgetown |
| Othella Harrington | Second Team | 1993-1994 | Georgetown |
| Othella Harrington | Third Team | 1995-1996 | Georgetown |
| Patrick Ewing | Second Team | 1981-1982 | Georgetown |
| Patrick Ewing | First Team | 1982-1983 | Georgetown |
| Patrick Ewing | First Team | 1983-1984 | Georgetown |
| Patrick Ewing | First Team | 1984-1985 | Georgetown |
| Perry McDonald | Second Team | 1986-1987 | Georgetown |
| Reggie Williams | First Team | 1985-1986 | Georgetown |
| Reggie Williams | First Team | 1986-1987 | Georgetown |
| Roy Hibbert | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Georgetown |
| Roy Hibbert | First Team | 2006-2007 | Georgetown |
| Roy Hibbert | First Team | 2007-2008 | Georgetown |
| Ruben Boumtje Boumtje | Third Team | 1999-2000 | Georgetown |
| Victor Page | First Team | 1996-1997 | Georgetown |
| David Padgett | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Louisville |
| David Padgett | First Team | 2007-2008 | Louisville |
| Taquan Dean | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Louisville |
| Terrence Williams | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Louisville |
| Terrence Williams | Second Team | 2007-2008 | Louisville |
| Dominic James | Honorable Mention | 2005-2006 | Marquette |
| Dominic James | First Team | 2006-2007 | Marquette |
| Dominic James | Second Team | 2007-2008 | Marquette |
| Jerel McNeal | Second Team | 2006-2007 | Marquette |
| Jerel McNeal | Second Team | 2007-2008 | Marquette |
| Lazar Hayward | Second Team | 2007-2008 | Marquette |
| Steve Novak | First Team | 2005-2006 | Marquette |
| Constantin Popa | Third Team | 1992-1993 | Miami |
| Constantin Popa | Third Team | 1994-1995 | Miami |
| Darius Rice | Second Team | 2001-2002 | Miami |
| Darius Rice | Third Team | 2002-2003 | Miami |
| Darius Rice | Second Team | 2003-2004 | Miami |
| James Jones | Third Team | 2001-2002 | Miami |
| James Jones | Honorable Mention | 2002-2003 | Miami |
| John Salmons | Third Team | 2000-2001 | Miami |
| John Salmons | Second Team | 2001-2002 | Miami |
| Johnny Hemsley | First Team | 1998-1999 | Miami |
| Johnny Hemsley | Second Team | 1999-2000 | Miami |
| Mario Bland | Third Team | 1999-2000 | Miami |
| Tim James | Second Team | 1996-1997 | Miami |
| Tim James | First Team | 1997-1998 | Miami |
| Tim James | First Team | 1998-1999 | Miami |
| Chris Quinn | First Team | 2005-2006 | Notre Dame |
| Chris Thomas | Third Team | 2001-2002 | Notre Dame |
| Chris Thomas | Second Team | 2002-2003 | Notre Dame |
| Chris Thomas | Second Team | 2003-2004 | Notre Dame |
| Chris Thomas | Third Team | 2004-2005 | Notre Dame |
| Colin Falls | First Team | 2006-2007 | Notre Dame |
| David Graves | Honorable Mention | 2001-2002 | Notre Dame |
| Kyle McAlarney | First Team | 2007-2008 | Notre Dame |
| Luke Harangody | First Team | 2007-2008 | Notre Dame |
| Matt Carroll | First Team | 2002-2003 | Notre Dame |
| Pat Garrity | Third Team | 1995-1996 | Notre Dame |
| Pat Garrity | First Team | 1996-1997 | Notre Dame |
| Pat Garrity | First Team | 1997-1998 | Notre Dame |
| Russell Carter | First Team | 2006-2007 | Notre Dame |
| Ryan Humphrey | Third Team | 2000-2001 | Notre Dame |
| Ryan Humphrey | First Team | 2001-2002 | Notre Dame |
| Torin Francis | Honorable Mention | 2003-2004 | Notre Dame |
| Troy Murphy | Second Team | 1998-1999 | Notre Dame |
| Troy Murphy | First Team | 1999-2000 | Notre Dame |
| Troy Murphy | First Team | 2000-2001 | Notre Dame |
| Aaron Gray | First Team | 2005-2006 | Pittsburgh |
| Aaron Gray | First Team | 2006-2007 | Pittsburgh |
| Brandin Knight | First Team | 2001-2002 | Pittsburgh |
| Brandin Knight | Second Team | 2002-2003 | Pittsburgh |
| Brian Shorter | First Team | 1988-1989 | Pittsburgh |
| Brian Shorter | First Team | 1989-1990 | Pittsburgh |
| Brian Shorter | Second Team | 1990-1991 | Pittsburgh |
| Carl Krauser | Second Team | 2003-2004 | Pittsburgh |
| Carl Krauser | Second Team | 2004-2005 | Pittsburgh |
| Carl Krauser | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Pittsburgh |
| Charles Smith | Third Team | 1984-1985 | Pittsburgh |
| Charles Smith | Third Team | 1985-1986 | Pittsburgh |
| Charles Smith | First Team | 1986-1987 | Pittsburgh |
| Charles Smith | First Team | 1987-1988 | Pittsburgh |
| Chevon Troutman | Third Team | 2002-2003 | Pittsburgh |
| Chevy Troutman | First Team | 2004-2005 | Pittsburgh |
| Chris Taft | Third Team | 2003-2004 | Pittsburgh |
| Chris Taft | Honorable Mention | 2004-2005 | Pittsburgh |
| Clyde Vaughan | Third Team | 1982-1983 | Pittsburgh |
| Clyde Vaughan | Second Team | 1983-1984 | Pittsburgh |
| Darren Morningstar | Third Team | 1991-1992 | Pittsburgh |
| DeJuan Blair | Honorable Mention | 2007-2008 | Pittsburgh |
| Demetreus Gore | Third Team | 1985-1986 | Pittsburgh |
| Eric Mobley | Third Team | 1993-1994 | Pittsburgh |
| Isaac Hawkins | Third Team | 1998-1999 | Pittsburgh |
| Jaime Peterson | Second Team | 1994-1995 | Pittsburgh |
| Jaron Brown | Honorable Mention | 2001-2002 | Pittsburgh |
| Jaron Brown | Second Team | 2003-2004 | Pittsburgh |
| Jason Matthews | Third Team | 1988-1989 | Pittsburgh |
| Jason Matthews | Third Team | 1989-1990 | Pittsburgh |
| Jason Matthews | Third Team | 1990-1991 | Pittsburgh |
| Jerome Lane | First Team | 1986-1987 | Pittsburgh |
| Jerome Lane | Second Team | 1987-1988 | Pittsburgh |
| Jerry McCullough | Second Team | 1992-1993 | Pittsburgh |
| Jerry McCullough | Third Team | 1993-1994 | Pittsburgh |
| Julius Page | Honorable Mention | 2001-2002 | Pittsburgh |
| Julius Page | Third Team | 2002-2003 | Pittsburgh |
| Julius Page | Honorable Mention | 2003-2004 | Pittsburgh |
| Levance Fields | Second Team | 2006-2007 | Pittsburgh |
| Ontario Lett | Honorable Mention | 2002-2003 | Pittsburgh |
| Ricardo Greer | Second Team | 1999-2000 | Pittsburgh |
| Ricardo Greer | Second Team | 2000-2001 | Pittsburgh |
| Sam Young | First Team | 2007-2008 | Pittsburgh |
| Sean Miller | Second Team | 1991-1992 | Pittsburgh |
| Vonteego Cummings | Second Team | 1996-1997 | Pittsburgh |
| Vonteego Cummings | Second Team | 1997-1998 | Pittsburgh |
| Vonteego Cummings | Third Team | 1998-1999 | Pittsburgh |
| Austin Croshere | Third Team | 1995-1996 | Providence |
| Austin Croshere | First Team | 1996-1997 | Providence |
| Billy Donovan | Third Team | 1985-1986 | Providence |
| Billy Donovan | First Team | 1986-1987 | Providence |
| Carlton Screen | Second Team | 1989-1990 | Providence |
| David Kipfer | Third Team | 1986-1987 | Providence |
| Derrick Brown | Third Team | 1996-1997 | Providence |
| Donnie McGrath | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Providence |
| Eric Murdock | Third Team | 1988-1989 | Providence |
| Eric Murdock | First Team | 1990-1991 | Providence |
| Eric Williams | First Team | 1994-1995 | Providence |
| Geoff McDermott | Honorable Mention | 2006-2007 | Providence |
| Geoff McDermott | Honorable Mention | 2007-2008 | Providence |
| Herbert Hill | First Team | 2006-2007 | Providence |
| Jamel Thomas | Second Team | 1997-1998 | Providence |
| Jamel Thomas | First Team | 1998-1999 | Providence |
| John Linehan | Second Team | 2000-2001 | Providence |
| John Linehan | Second Team | 2001-2002 | Providence |
| Marques Bragg | Third Team | 1991-1992 | Providence |
| Marty Conlon | Third Team | 1989-1990 | Providence |
| Michael Smith | Third Team | 1991-1992 | Providence |
| Michael Smith | Second Team | 1992-1993 | Providence |
| Michael Smith | Second Team | 1993-1994 | Providence |
| Otis Thorpe | Third Team | 1981-1982 | Providence |
| Otis Thorpe | Third Team | 1982-1983 | Providence |
| Otis Thorpe | First Team | 1983-1984 | ProvIdence |
| Ron Jackson | Third Team | 1981-1982 | ProvIdence |
| Ron Jackson | Third Team | 1982-1983 | ProvIdence |
| Rudy Williams | Third Team | 1979-1980 | Providence |
| Ryan Gomes | Second Team | 2002-2003 | Providence |
| Ryan Gomes | First Team | 2003-2004 | Providence |
| Ryan Gomes | First Team | 2004-2005 | Providence |
| Sharaud Curry | Honorable Mention | 2006-2007 | Providence |
| Steve Wright | Third Team | 1987-1988 | Providence |
| Damon Santiago | Second Team | 1995-1996 | Rutgers |
| Herve Lamizana | Third Team | 2003-2004 | Rutgers |
| Jerome Coleman | Honorable Mention | 2001-2002 | Rutgers |
| Quincy Douby | First Team | 2005-2006 | Rutgers |
| Rashod Kent | Second Team | 2001-2002 | Rutgers |
| Rob Hodgson | Third Team | 1998-1999 | Rutgers |
| Todd Billet | Third Team | 2000-2001 | Rutgers |
| Adrian Griffin | Third Team | 1994-1995 | Seton Hall |
| Adrian Griffin | Second Team | 1995-1996 | Seton Hall |
| Andre Barrett | Second Team | 2002-2003 | Seton Hall |
| Andre Barrett | First Team | 2003-2004 | Seton Hall |
| Andre McCloud | Third Team | 1983-1984 | Seton Hall |
| Andre McCloud | Third Team | 1984-1985 | Seton Hall |
| Andrew Gaze | Third Team | 1988-1989 | Seton Hall |
| Anthony Avent | Second Team | 1990-1991 | Seton Hall |
| Arturas Karnishovas | Second Team | 1992-1993 | Seton Hall |
| Arturas Karnishovas | Second Team | 1993-1994 | Seton Hall |
| Brian Laing | Second Team | 2006-2007 | Seton Hall |
| Brian Laing | First Team | 2007-2008 | Seton Hall |
| Dan Callandrillo | Second Team | 1979-1980 | Seton Hall |
| Dan Callandrillo | Second Team | 1980-1981 | Seton Hall |
| Dan Callandrillo | First Team | 1981-1982 | Seton Hall |
| Donald Copeland | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Seton Hall |
| Eddie Griffin | Second Team | 2000-2001 | Seton Hall |
| Howard McNeil | Third Team | 1980-1981 | Seton Hall |
| James Major | Third Team | 1986-1987 | Seton Hall |
| Jerry Walker | Second Team | 1991-1992 | Seton Hall |
| Jerry Walker | Third Team | 1992-1993 | Seton Hall |
| John Morton | Third Team | 1988-1989 | Seton Hall |
| Kelly Whitney | Honorable Mention | 2003-2004 | Seton Hall |
| Kelly Whitney | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Seton Hall |
| Levell Sanders | Second Team | 1997-1998 | Seton Hall |
| Mark Bryant | Second Team | 1986-1987 | Seton Hall |
| Mark Bryant | First Team | 1987-1988 | Seton Hall |
| Ramon Ramos | First Team | 1988-1989 | Seton Hall |
| Shaheen Holloway | Second Team | 1996-1997 | Seton Hall |
| Shaheen Holloway | Third Team | 1997-1998 | Seton Hall |
| Shaheen Holloway | Second Team | 1999-2000 | Seton Hall |
| Terry Dehere | First Team | 1990-1991 | Seton Hall |
| Terry Dehere | First Team | 1991-1992 | Seton Hall |
| Terry Dehere | First Team | 1992-1993 | Seton Hall |
| Dominique Jones | Honorable Mention | 2007-2008 | South Florida |
| Kentrell Gransberry | Second Team | 2006-2007 | South Florida |
| Kentrell Gransberry | First Team | 2007-2008 | South Florida |
| McHugh Mattis | Honorable Mention | 2006-2007 | South Florida |
| Solomon Jones | Honorable Mention | 2005-2006 | South Florida |
| Anthony Mason, Jr. | Honorable Mention | 2007-2008 | St John's |
| Bill Wennington | Third Team | 1983-1984 | St John’s |
| Bill Wennington | Second Team | 1984-1985 | St John’s |
| Billy Goodwin | Third Team | 1981-1982 | St John’s |
| Billy Goodwin | Third Team | 1982-1983 | St John’s |
| Chris Mullin | Second Team | 1981-1982 | St John’s |
| Chris Mullin | First Team | 1982-1983 | St John’s |
| Chris Mullin | First Team | 1983-1984 | St John’s |
| Chris Mullin | First Team | 1984-1985 | St John’s |
| David Cain | First Team | 1992-1993 | St John’s |
| DavId Russell | Second Team | 1979-1980 | St John’s |
| David Russell | Second Team | 1980-1981 | St John’s |
| DavId Russell | First Team | 1981-1982 | St John’s |
| David Russell | Second Team | 1982-1983 | St John’s |
| Felipe Lopez | Third Team | 1994-1995 | St John’s |
| Felipe Lopez | Third Team | 1996-1997 | St John’s |
| Felipe Lopez | First Team | 1997-1998 | St John’s |
| Frank Gilroy | Third Team | 1980-1981 | St John’s |
| Greg “Boo” Harvey | First Team | 1989-1990 | St John’s |
| Jason Buchanan | Second Team | 1990-1991 | St John’s |
| Jayson Williams | Second Team | 1988-1989 | St John’s |
| Lamont Hamilton | Honorable Mention | 2005-2006 | St John's |
| Lamont Hamilton | First Team | 2006-2007 | St John's |
| Lamont Middleton | Third Team | 1992-1993 | St John’s |
| Malik Sealy | Second Team | 1989-1990 | St John’s |
| Malik Sealy | First Team | 1990-1991 | St John’s |
| Malik Sealy | First Team | 1991-1992 | St John’s |
| Mark Jackson | First Team | 1985-1986 | St John’s |
| Mark Jackson | First Team | 1986-1987 | St John’s |
| Michael Porter | Third Team | 1987-1988 | St John’s |
| Mike Moses | Third Team | 1984-1985 | St John’s |
| Reggie Carter | First Team | 1979-1980 | St John’s |
| Robert Werdann | Third Team | 1990-1991 | St John’s |
| Shawnelle Scott | Second Team | 1992-1993 | St John’s |
| Shawnelle Scott | Third Team | 1993-1994 | St John’s |
| Shelton Jones | Second Team | 1987-1988 | St John’s |
| Walter Berry | Second Team | 1984-1985 | St John’s |
| Walter Berry | First Team | 1985-1986 | St John’s |
| Wayne McKoy | Second Team | 1979-1980 | St John’s |
| Wayne McKoy | Third Team | 1980-1981 | St John’s |
| Willie Glass | Third Team | 1986-1987 | St John’s |
| Zendon Hamilton | Second Team | 1995-1996 | St John’s |
| Zendon Hamilton | Second Team | 1996-1997 | St John’s |
| Zendon Hamilton | Second Team | 1997-1998 | St John’s |
| Bootsy Thornton | Second Team | 1998-1999 | St John's |
| Bootsy Thornton | Third Team | 1999-2000 | St John's |
| Daryll Hill | Third Team | 2004-2005 | St John's |
| Erick Barkley | First Team | 1999-2000 | St John's |
| Lavor Postell | Second Team | 1999-2000 | St John's |
| Marcus Hatten | First Team | 2001-2002 | St John's |
| Marcus Hatten | First Team | 2002-2003 | St John's |
| Omar Cook | Third Team | 2000-2001 | St John's |
| Ron Artest | First Team | 1998-1999 | St John's |
| Adrian Autry | Third Team | 1992-1993 | Syracuse |
| Adrian Autry | First Team | 1993-1994 | Syracuse |
| Billy Owens | First Team | 1989-1990 | Syracuse |
| Billy Owens | First Team | 1990-1991 | Syracuse |
| Carmelo Anthony | First Team | 2002-2003 | Syracuse |
| Damone Brown | Second Team | 2000-2001 | Syracuse |
| Dan Schayes | First Team | 1980-1981 | Syracuse |
| Dave Johnson | Second Team | 1990-1991 | Syracuse |
| Dave Johnson | First Team | 1991-1992 | Syracuse |
| Demetris Nichols | First Team | 2006-2007 | Syracuse |
| Derrick Coleman | Third Team | 1986-1987 | Syracuse |
| Derrick Coleman | First Team | 1987-1988 | Syracuse |
| Derrick Coleman | First Team | 1988-1989 | Syracuse |
| Derrick Coleman | First Team | 1989-1990 | Syracuse |
| DeShaun Williams | Third Team | 2001-2002 | Syracuse |
| Donte´ Greene | Second Team | 2007-2008 | Syracuse |
| Dwayne 'Pearl' Washington | First Team | 1983-1984 | Syracuse |
| Dwayne 'Pearl' Washington | First Team | 1984-1985 | Syracuse |
| Dwayne 'Pearl' Washington | First Team | 1985-1986 | Syracuse |
| Eddie Moss | Third Team | 1979-1980 | Syracuse |
| Eric Devendorf | Honorable Mention | 2006-2007 | Syracuse |
| Erich Santifer | Second Team | 1981-1982 | Syracuse |
| Erich Santifer | First Team | 1982-1983 | Syracuse |
| Etan Thomas | Third Team | 1997-1998 | Syracuse |
| Etan Thomas | Second Team | 1998-1999 | Syracuse |
| Etan Thomas | First Team | 1999-2000 | Syracuse |
| Gerry McNamara | Second Team | 2003-2004 | Syracuse |
| Gerry McNamara | First Team | 2004-2005 | Syracuse |
| Gerry McNamara | First Team | 2005-2006 | Syracuse |
| Greg Monroe | Third Team | 1986-1987 | Syracuse |
| Hakim Warrick | Third Team | 2002-2003 | Syracuse |
| Hakim Warrick | First Team | 2003-2004 | Syracuse |
| Hakim Warrick | First Team | 2004-2005 | Syracuse |
| Jason Cipolla | Third Team | 1996-1997 | Syracuse |
| Jason Hart | Third Team | 1998-1999 | Syracuse |
| Jason Hart | First Team | 1999-2000 | Syracuse |
| John Wallace | Second Team | 1993-1994 | Syracuse |
| John Wallace | First Team | 1994-1995 | Syracuse |
| John Wallace | First Team | 1995-1996 | Syracuse |
| Jonny Flynn | Honorable Mention | 2007-2008 | Syracuse |
| Josh Pace | Honorable Mention | 2004-2005 | Syracuse |
| Lawrence Moten | Third Team | 1991-1992 | Syracuse |
| Lawrence Moten | First Team | 1992-1993 | Syracuse |
| Lawrence Moten | First Team | 1993-1994 | Syracuse |
| Lawrence Moten | First Team | 1994-1995 | Syracuse |
| Leo Rautins | Third Team | 1982-1983 | Syracuse |
| Louis Orr | First Team | 1979-1980 | Syracuse |
| Marty Headd | Third Team | 1979-1980 | Syracuse |
| Marty Headd | Second Team | 1980-1981 | Syracuse |
| Otis Hill | Second Team | 1996-1997 | Syracuse |
| Paul Harris | Second Team | 2007-2008 | Syracuse |
| Preston Shumpert | First Team | 2000-2001 | Syracuse |
| Preston Shumpert | First Team | 2001-2002 | Syracuse |
| Rafael Addison | Second Team | 1983-1984 | Syracuse |
| Rafael Addison | First Team | 1984-1985 | Syracuse |
| Rafael Addison | Second Team | 1985-1986 | Syracuse |
| Rony Seikaly | Second Team | 1985-1986 | Syracuse |
| Rony Seikaly | Second Team | 1986-1987 | Syracuse |
| Rony Seikaly | Second Team | 1987-1988 | Syracuse |
| Roosevelt Bouie | First Team | 1979-1980 | Syracuse |
| Ryan Blackwell | Third Team | 1999-2000 | Syracuse |
| Sherman Douglas | First Team | 1986-1987 | Syracuse |
| Sherman Douglas | First Team | 1987-1988 | Syracuse |
| Sherman Douglas | First Team | 1988-1989 | Syracuse |
| Stevie Thompson | Second Team | 1988-1989 | Syracuse |
| Stevie Thompson | Second Team | 1989-1990 | Syracuse |
| Todd Burgan | Second Team | 1997-1998 | Syracuse |
| Tony Bruin | Third Team | 1981-1982 | Syracuse |
| Wendell Alexis | Second Team | 1985-1986 | Syracuse |
| Allan Ray | Third Team | 2003-2004 | Villanova |
| Allan Ray | Second Team | 2004-2005 | Villanova |
| Allan Ray | First Team | 2005-2006 | Villanova |
| Alvin Williams | First Team | 1996-1997 | Villanova |
| Curtis Sumpter | Third Team | 2003-2004 | Villanova |
| Curtis Sumpter | Second Team | 2004-2005 | Villanova |
| Curtis Sumpter | First Team | 2006-2007 | Villanova |
| Doug West | Second Team | 1987-1988 | Villanova |
| Doug West | Third Team | 1988-1989 | Villanova |
| Dwayne McClain | Third Team | 1983-1984 | Villanova |
| Dwayne McClain | Third Team | 1984-1985 | Villanova |
| Ed Pinckney | First Team | 1982-1983 | Villanova |
| Ed Pinckney | Second Team | 1983-1984 | Villanova |
| Ed Pinckney | First Team | 1984-1985 | Villanova |
| Eric Eberz | Second Team | 1994-1995 | Villanova |
| Gary Buchanan | Honorable Mention | 2001-2002 | Villanova |
| Gary Buchanan | Honorable Mention | 2002-2003 | Villanova |
| Harold Jensen | Second Team | 1986-1987 | Villanova |
| Harold Pressley | Third Team | 1983-1984 | Villanova |
| Harold Pressley | First Team | 1985-1986 | Villanova |
| Jason Lawson | Second Team | 1994-1995 | Villanova |
| Jason Lawson | Second Team | 1995-1996 | Villanova |
| Jason Lawson | Second Team | 1996-1997 | Villanova |
| John Celestand | Third Team | 1998-1999 | Villanova |
| John Pinone | First Team | 1980-1981 | Villanova |
| John Pinone | First Team | 1981-1982 | Villanova |
| John Pinone | First Team | 1982-1983 | Villanova |
| Kerry Kittles | First Team | 1993-1994 | Villanova |
| Kerry Kittles | First Team | 1994-1995 | Villanova |
| Kerry Kittles | First Team | 1995-1996 | Villanova |
| Kyle Lowry | Second Team | 2005-2006 | Villanova |
| Lance Miller | Third Team | 1990-1991 | Villanova |
| Lance Miller | Second Team | 1991-1992 | Villanova |
| Malik Allen | Second Team | 1999-2000 | Villanova |
| Mark Plansky | Third Team | 1987-1988 | Villanova |
| Michael Bradley | First Team | 2000-2001 | Villanova |
| Mike Nardi | Honorable Mention | 2006-2007 | Villanova |
| Randy Foye | Third Team | 2004-2005 | Villanova |
| Randy Foye | First Team | 2005-2006 | Villanova |
| Ricky Wright | Second Team | 2001-2002 | Villanova |
| Ricky Wright | Honorable Mention | 2002-2003 | Villanova |
| Scottie Reynolds | Second Team | 2006-2007 | Villanova |
| Scottie Reynolds | Second Team | 2007-2008 | Villanova |
| Stewart Granger | Third Team | 1980-1981 | Villanova |
| Stewart Granger | Second Team | 1981-1982 | Villanova |
| Stewart Granger | Second Team | 1982-1983 | Villanova |
| Tim Thomas | Third Team | 1996-1997 | Villanova |
| Tom Greis | Third Team | 1987-1988 | Villanova |
| Bryant Matthews | Honorable Mention | 2002-2003 | Virginia Tech |
| Bryant Matthews | First Team | 2003-2004 | Virginia Tech |
| Terry Taylor | Honorable Mention | 2002-2003 | Virginia Tech |
| Calvin Bowman | First Team | 2000-2001 | West Virginia |
| Chris Moss | Third Team | 2001-2002 | West Virginia |
| Damian Owens | Third Team | 1995-1996 | West Virginia |
| Damian Owens | Third Team | 1996-1997 | West Virginia |
| Damian Owens | First Team | 1997-1998 | West Virginia |
| Drew Schifino | Third Team | 2002-2003 | West Virginia |
| Frank Young | First Team | 2006-2007 | West Virginia |
| Joe Alexander | First Team | 2007-2008 | West Virginia |
| Kevin Pittsnogle | First Team | 2005-2006 | West Virginia |
| Marcus Goree | Second Team | 1998-1999 | West Virginia |
| Marcus Goree | Third Team | 1999-2000 | West Virginia |
| Mike Gansey | First Team | 2005-2006 | West Virginia |
| Tyrone Sally | Honorable Mention | 2004-2005 | West Virginia |
©RLYoung 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008